MELHORES DISCOS DE 2010 - LISTAS DA CRÍTICA MUNDIAL

Este post eu escrevo com um gosto especial. É que foi justamente para compartilhar certas manias que eu decidi montar um blog e chamar um camarada para tocá-lo comigo.

E uma das manias que eu tinha era a de ficar pesquisando todas as listas de melhores do ano que a crítica especializada liberava. Depois ficava comparando uma com a outra e tal. Coisa de maluco.

Desde o ano passado eu já posso compartilhar o resultado desta pesquisa com vocês (leia aqui as listas de 2009). Dá um trabalho grande, mas faço por lazer.

Desta vez eu ampliei a base de consulta e ao invés de 16 listas, temos abaixo 21. São publicações respeitadas e importantes fontes de informação não só para mim como para a imensa maioria dos "especialistas" brasucas. Tem muito pedante inclusive que adora fazer sua própria relação só com cópias destas aí embaixo.

É importante dizer que estas listas em sua grande maioria são compostas por 50, 40 albuns. Como fica inviável transcrever tudo isso para cá, mostrei somente o top 10 de cada uma. São destaques os discos do Arcade Fire, do Kanye West e do LCD Soundsystem, todos entre os melhores em mais da metade do que foi pesquisado.

Ainda esta semana eu e o Anselmo vamos mandar um post com os nossos discos favoritos (não melhores) do ano.

Por ora, as listas:

New Musical Express
1) These New Puritans - "Hidden"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
4) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
5) Laura Marling - "I Speak Because I Can"
6) Foals - "Total Life Forever"
7) Zola Jesus - "Stridulum II"
8) Salem - "King Night"
9) Liars - "Sisterworld"
10) The Drums - "The Drums"

Spin
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) Deerhunter - "Halcyon Digest"
3) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
4) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
5) Jamey Johnson - "The Guitar Song"
6) Janelle Monae - "The ArchAndroid"
7) Grinderman - "Grinderman 2"
8) M.I.A. - "Maya"
9) Kid Cudi - "Man on the Moon II"
10) Robyn - "Body Talk"

Q Magazine
1) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
2) Robert Plant - "Band of Joy"
3) Plan B - "The Deformation of Strickland Banks"
4) Laura Marling - "I Speak Because I Can"
5) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
6) John Grant - "Queen of Denmark"
7) Gorillaz - "Plastic Beach"
8) The National - "High Violet"
9) Paul Weller - "Wake up the Nation"
10) MGMT - "Congratulations"

Uncut
1) Joanna Newsom - "Have One on Me"
2) Neil Young - "Le Noise"
3) Paul Weller - "Wake up the Nation"
4) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
5) Robert Plant - "Band of Joy"
6) Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti - "Before Today"
7) John Grant - "Queen of Denmark"
8) Ali Farka Toure and Toumani Diabata - "Ali ans Toumani"
9) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
10) Grinderman - "Grinderman 2"

Rolling Stone
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
3) Elton John and Leon Russel - "The Union"
4) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
5) Jamey Johnson - "The Guitar Song"
6) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
7) Drake - "Thank me Later"
8) Robert Plant - "Band of Joy"
9) Eminen - "Recovery"
10) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"

Mojo
1) John Grant - "Queen of Denmark"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) MGMT - "Congratulations"
4) Edwyn Colllins - "Losing Sleep"
5) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
6) Paul Weller - "Wake up the Nation"
7) Midlake - "The Courage of Others"
8) Phosphorescent - "Here's to Taking it Easy"
9) The Coral - "Butterfly House"
10) Doug Paisley - "Constant Companion"

Pitchfork
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
3) Deerhunter - "Halcyon Digest"
4) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"
5) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
6) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
7) Joanna Newsom - "Have One on Me"
8) James Blake - "The Bells Sketch / CMYK / Klavierwerke"
9) Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti - "Before Today"
10) Titus Andronicus - "The Monitor"

Gigwise
1) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
2) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
3) The National - "High Violet"
4) Drake - "Thank me Later"
5) Everything Everything - "Man Alive"
6) Foals - "Total Life Forever"
7) Caribou - "Swim"
8) These New Puritans - "Hidden"
9) Warpaint - "The Fool"
10) My Chemical Romance - "Danger Days..."

Paste Magazine
1) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
2) Janelle Monae - "The ArchAndroid"
3) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
4) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
5) Titus Andronicus - "The Monitor"
6) Sleigh Bells - "Treats"
7) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
8) Phosphorescent - "Here's to Taking it Easy"
9) Sufjan Stevens - "The Age of Adz"
10) Frightened Robbit - "The Winter of Mixed Drinks"

Guardian
1) Janelle Monae - "The ArchAndroid"
2) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
3) Hot Chip - "One Life Stand"
4) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
5) These New Puritans - "Hidden"
6) Caribou - "Swim"
7) Robyn - "Body Talk"
8) Laura Marling - "I Speak Because I Can"
9) Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti - "Before Today"
10) John Grant - "Queen of Denmark"

Time
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
4) The National - "High Violet"
5) Drake - "Thank me Later"
6) Sufjan Stevens - "The Age of Adz"
7) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
8) Yeasayer - "Odd Blood"
9) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"
10) Beach House - "Teen Dream"

Billboard
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) Robyn - "Body Talk"
4) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
5) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
6) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
7) Drake - "Thank me Later"
8) MGMT - "Congratulations"
9) Ricky Ross - "Teflon Don"
10) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"

Amazon
1) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
4) The National - "High Violet"
5) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
6) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
7) Broken Bells - "Broken Bells"
8) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
9) Deerhunter - "Halcyon Digest"
10) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"

American Songwriter
1) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
2) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
3) Dylan Le Blanc - "Pauper's Field"
4) Jamey Johnson - "The Guitar Song"
5) Yeasayer - "Odd Blood"
6) Robert Plant - "Band of Joy"
7) Phosphorescent - "Here's to Taking it Easy"
8) Neil Young - "Le Noise"
9) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
10) Laura Veirs - "July Flame"

Relevant
1) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
4) The Roots - "How I Got Over"
5) John Mark Mc Millan - "The Medicine"
6) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
7) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
8) Janelle Monae - "The ArchAndroid"
9) The National - "High Violet"
10) Local Natives - "Gorilla Manor"

Filter
1) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
2) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
3) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
4) The National - "High Violet"
5) The Walkmen - "Lisbon"
6) Gorillaz - "Plastic Beach"
7) Surfer Blood - "Astro Coast"
8) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
9) The Tallest Man on Earth - "The Wild Hunt"
10) Band of Horses - "Infinite Arms"

Magnet
1) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) The National - "High Violet"
4) Broken Bells - "Broken Bells"
5) Superchunk - "Majesty Shredding"
6) Jenny and Johnny - "I'm Having Fun Now"
7) Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti - "Before Today"
8) Teenage FanClub - "Shadows"
9) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
10) The New Pornographers - "Together"

Stereogum
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
4) Sufjan Stevens - "The Age of Adz"
5) Robyn - "Body Talk"
6) Sleigh Bells - "Treats"
7) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
8) Antony And The Johnsons - "Swanlights"
9) Wild Nothing - "Gemini"
10) Deerhunter - "Halcyon Digest"

Clash
1) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
2) Ganjasufi - "A Sufi and Killer"
3) Caribou - "Swim"
4) Pantha Du Prince - "Black Noise"
5) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
6) Band of Horses - "Infinite Arms"
7) Foals - "Total Life Forever"
8) Matthew Dear - "Black City"
9) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
10) These New Puritans - "Hidden"

Metacritic (discos com maior pontuação durante o ano)
1) Bruce Springsteen - "The Promisse"
2) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
3) Janelle Monae - "The ArchAndroid"
4) Jamey Johnson - "The Guitar Song"
5) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"
6) Underoath - "0"
7) Crime in Stereo - "I Was Trying to Describe You to Someone"
8) Ali Farka Toure and Toumani Diabata - "Ali ans Toumani"
9) Shakira - "Sale el Sol"
10) Marc Ribot - "Silent Movies"

BBC - Music Blog
1) Drake - "Thank me Later"
2) Deftones - "Diamond Eyes"
3) The Roots - "How I Got Over"
4) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"
5) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"


Sandro