MELHORES DISCOS DE 2009 - OPINIÃO DOS ESPECIALISTAS

Já escrevi aqui outras vezes que sou chegado em listas. Gosto de fazer, mas gosto muito de ver a dos outros também. Enquanto o Minerva Pop não publica sua lista de favoritos de 2009, vou deixar por aqui o resultado de uma pesquisa que eu fiz em vários sites especializados.

Considerando que grande parte do que lemos na mídia brasileira é "chupado" destas fontes e que nossos especialistas brasucas são fortemente influenciados por estes veículos de comunicação, certamente você verá o que está aí embaixo em muitas listas divulgadas aqui no Brasil.

Tem de tudo, alguma coisas desconhecidas e descartáveis, outras novidades de muita qualidade, além de uma pequena participação de artistas consagrados. Particularmente a que achei mais a legal foi a da revista britânica Q, pois me pareceu menos afetada.

A grande maioria elenca mais de 10 discos, os respectivos sites mostram as listas completas (exceção a Uncut e Mojo ,que peguei na versão impressa), por esta razão, vale a visita como curiosidade. Se conhecer alguma relevante que ficou de fora, manda para a gente (a Blender e a Filter ainda não publicaram suas listas) completar.

Agora, as listas:

New Musical Express
1) The Horrors - "Primary Colours"
2) The XX - "The xx"
3) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "It's Blitz"
4) Wild Beasts - "Two Dancers"
5) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
6) Grizzly Bear - "Veckatimest"
7) The Big Pink - "A Brief History of Love"
8) Fuck Buttons - "Tarot Sport"
9) Fever Ray - "Fever Ray"
10) Jamie T - "Kings and Queens"

Spin
1) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
2) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "It's Blitz"
3) Phoenix - "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix"
4) Grizzly Bear - "Veckatimest"
5) Girls - "Album"
6) Bat For Lashes - "Two Suns"
7) Mos Def - "The Ecstatic"
8) Florence and The Machine - "Lungs"
9) Drake - "So Far Gone"
10) The Dead Weather - "Horebound"

Q Magazine
1) Kasabian - "West Ryder Pauper Lunatic Asylum"
2) Florence and The Machine - "Lungs"
3) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "It's Blitz"
4) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
5) Manic Street Preachers - "Journal For Plague Lovers"
6) Artic Monkeys - "Humbug"
7) Muse - "The Resistance"
8) Lily Allen - "It's Not me, It's You"
9) U2 - "No Line on the Horizon"
10) Phoenix - "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix"

Uncut
1) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
2) Super Furruy Animals - "Dark Days / Light Years"
3) Dirty Projectors - "Bitte Orca"
4) Bob Dylan - "Together Through Life"
5) Wild Beasts - "Two Dancers"
6) The XX - "The xx"
7) Wilco - "Wilco (The Album)"
8) Grizzly Bear - "Veckatimest"
9) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "It's Blitz"
10) Phoenix - "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix"

Rolling Stone
1) U2 - "No Line on the Horizon"
2) Bruce Springsteen - "Working on a Dream"
3) Phoenix - "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix"
4) Jay Z - "The Blueprint 3"
5) Green Day - "21st Century Breakdown"
6) Dirty Projectors - "Bitte Orca"
7) Necko Case - "Middle Cyclone"
8) The Dream - "Love vs Eternal"
9) The XX - "The xx"
10) Sonic Youth - "The Eternal"

Mojo
1) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
2) Bill Calahan - "Sometimes I Wish I Were an Eagle"
3) Richard Hawley - "Truelove Gutter"
4) The Horrors - "Primary Colours"
5) Tinariwen - "Imidiwan: Companions"
6) Bob Dylan - "Together Through Life"
7) Florence and The Machine - "Lungs"
8) Fuck Buttons - "Tarot Sport"
9) Madness - "The Liberty of Nolton Folgate"
10) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "It's Blitz"

Pitchfork
1) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
2) Dirty Projectors - "Bitte Orca"
3) The XX - "The xx"
4) The Flaming Lips - "Embryonic"
5) Raeknown - "Only Buit For Cuban Line"
6) Grizzly Bear - "Veckatimest"
7) Bat For Lashes - "Two Suns"
8) Phoenix - "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix"
9) Fever Ray - "Fever Ray"
10) Girls - "Album"

Guardian
1) The XX - "The xx"
2) Fever Ray - "Fever Ray"
3) Wild Beasts - "Two Dancers"
4) Dirty Projectors - "Bitte Orca"
5) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
6) Florence and The Machine - "Lungs"
7) Noah and The Whole - "The First Days of Spring"
8) Micachu and The Shapes - "Jewellery"
9) La Roux - "La Roux"
10) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "It's Blitz"

Metacritic
1) Nirvana - "Live at Reading"
2) Leonard Cohen - "Live in London"
3) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
4) Raeknwon - "Only Buit For Cuban Line"
5) Baroness - "Blue Record"
6) Sunn O - "Monoliths And Dimensions"
7) Brad Paisley - "American Saturday Night"
8) Amadou and Mariam - "Welcome to Mali"
9) The Antlers - "Hospice"
10) Manic Street Preachers - "Journal For Plague Lovers"

Billboard (lista dos críticos)
1) Jay Z - "The Blueprint 3"
2) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "It's Blitz"
3) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
4) Phoenix - "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix"
5) Necko Case - "Middle Cyclone"
6) Wilco - "Wilco (The Album)
7) Dirty Projectors - "Bitte Orca"
8) Pearl Jam - "Backspacer"
9) Grizzly Bear - "Veckatimest"
10) K'Naan - "Troubadour"

Relevant
1) Grizzly Bear - "Veckatimest"
2) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
3) The Avett Brothers - "I and Love and You"
4) Phoenix - "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix"
5) Kid Cudi - "Man on The Moon: The End of the Day"
6) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "It's Blitz"
7) Passion Pit - "Manners"
8) Paper Route - "Absence"
9) Derek Webb - "Stockholm Syyndrome"
10) Mos Def - " The Ecstatic"

Amazon
1) Grizzly Bear - "Veckatimest"
2) Fanfarlo - "Reservoir"
3) Necko Case - "Middle Cyclone"
4) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "It's Blitz"
5) Phoenix - "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix"
6) The XX - "The xx"
7) Edward Sharpe and The Magnetic Zeros - "Up From Below"
8) A.A. Bondy - "When The Devil's Loose"
9) The Big Pink - "A Brief History of Love"
10) The Avett Brothers - "I and Love and You"

7 Digital
1) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
2) The Horrors - "Primary Colours"
3) Wild Beasts - "Two Dancers"
4) The XX - "The xx"
5) Major Lazer - "Guns Don't Kill People...Lazers do
6) Grizzly Bear - "Veckatimest"
7) Florence and The Machine - "Lungs"
8) Phoenix - "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix"
9) Heath - "Get Color"
10) Mos Def - "The Ecstatic"

Gigwise
1) Wild Beasts - "Two Dancers"
2) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
3) Fuck Buttons - "Tarot Sport"
4) The Horrors - "Primary Colours"
5) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "It's Blitz"
6) Grizzly Bear - "Veckatimest"
7) The Maccabees - "Wall of Arms"
8) Fever Ray - "Fever Ray"
9) Royksopp - "Junior"
10)The XX - "The xx"

Paste Magazine
1) The Avett Brothers - "I and Love and You"
2) Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
3) Elvis Perkins in Dearland - "Elvis Perkins in Dearland"
4) The Low Anthem - "Oh My God,Charlie Darwin"
5) David Bazan - "Curse Your Branches"
6) Brandi Carlile - "Give Up The Ghost"
7) The Decemberists - "Hazards of Love"
8) Phoenix - "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix"
9) Necko Case - "Middle Cyclone"
10) Frank Turner - "Poetry of The Deed"

All Music Guide (listou os discos em ordem alfabética, escolhi os 10 com + de 4 estrelas)
Animal Collective - "Merriweather Post Pavilion"
Baroness - "Blue Record"
The Black Crowes - "Before the Frost/Until the Freeze"
The Dream - "Love vs Money"
Jarvis Cocker - "Further Complications"
Madness - "The Liberty of Norton Folgate"
Manic Street Preachers - "Journal For Plague Lovers"
Norah Jones - "The Fall"
Sunn O - "Monoliths And Dimensions"
Weezer - "Raditude"

Amanhã eu coloco vídeos de alguns dos listados acima.


Atualização do post em 16.01:

Rolling Stone Brasil - discos internacionais
1) Franz Ferdinand - "Tonight"
2) Them Crooked Vultures - "Them Crooked Vultures"
3) Air - "Love 2"
4) Artic Monkeys - "Humbug"
5) Lily Allen - "It's Not Me, It's You"
6) Leonard Cohen - "Live in London"
7) Black Eyed Peas - "The E.N.D."
8) Norah Jones - "The Fall"
9) U2 - "No Line on the Horizon"
10) Morrissey - "Years of Refusal"

Rolling Stone Brasil - discos nacionais
1) Céu - "Vagarosa"
2) Cidadão Instigado - "Uhuu!"
3) Erasmo Carlos - "Rock 'n' Roll"
4) Arnaldo Antunes - "Iê Iê Iê"
5) Móveis Coloniais de Acaju - "C_mpl_te"
6) Black Drawing Chalks - "Life is a Big Holiday for Us"
7) Mariana Aydar - "Peixes Pássaros Pessoas"
8) Lucas Santana - "Sem Nostalgia"
9) Wado - "Atlântico Negro"
10) Mallu Magalhães - "Mallu Magalhãesl"

Sandro