minervapop

quarta-feira, 22 de dezembro de 2010

MELHORES DISCOS DE 2010 - LISTAS DA CRÍTICA MUNDIAL

Este post eu escrevo com um gosto especial. É que foi justamente para compartilhar certas manias que eu decidi montar um blog e chamar um camarada para tocá-lo comigo.

E uma das manias que eu tinha era a de ficar pesquisando todas as listas de melhores do ano que a crítica especializada liberava. Depois ficava comparando uma com a outra e tal. Coisa de maluco.

Desde o ano passado eu já posso compartilhar o resultado desta pesquisa com vocês (leia aqui as listas de 2009). Dá um trabalho grande, mas faço por lazer.

Desta vez eu ampliei a base de consulta e ao invés de 16 listas, temos abaixo 21. São publicações respeitadas e importantes fontes de informação não só para mim como para a imensa maioria dos "especialistas" brasucas. Tem muito pedante inclusive que adora fazer sua própria relação só com cópias destas aí embaixo.

É importante dizer que estas listas em sua grande maioria são compostas por 50, 40 albuns. Como fica inviável transcrever tudo isso para cá, mostrei somente o top 10 de cada uma. São destaques os discos do Arcade Fire, do Kanye West e do LCD Soundsystem, todos entre os melhores em mais da metade do que foi pesquisado.

Ainda esta semana eu e o Anselmo vamos mandar um post com os nossos discos favoritos (não melhores) do ano.

Por ora, as listas:

New Musical Express
1) These New Puritans - "Hidden"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
4) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
5) Laura Marling - "I Speak Because I Can"
6) Foals - "Total Life Forever"
7) Zola Jesus - "Stridulum II"
8) Salem - "King Night"
9) Liars - "Sisterworld"
10) The Drums - "The Drums"

Spin
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) Deerhunter - "Halcyon Digest"
3) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
4) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
5) Jamey Johnson - "The Guitar Song"
6) Janelle Monae - "The ArchAndroid"
7) Grinderman - "Grinderman 2"
8) M.I.A. - "Maya"
9) Kid Cudi - "Man on the Moon II"
10) Robyn - "Body Talk"

Q Magazine
1) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
2) Robert Plant - "Band of Joy"
3) Plan B - "The Deformation of Strickland Banks"
4) Laura Marling - "I Speak Because I Can"
5) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
6) John Grant - "Queen of Denmark"
7) Gorillaz - "Plastic Beach"
8) The National - "High Violet"
9) Paul Weller - "Wake up the Nation"
10) MGMT - "Congratulations"

Uncut
1) Joanna Newsom - "Have One on Me"
2) Neil Young - "Le Noise"
3) Paul Weller - "Wake up the Nation"
4) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
5) Robert Plant - "Band of Joy"
6) Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti - "Before Today"
7) John Grant - "Queen of Denmark"
8) Ali Farka Toure and Toumani Diabata - "Ali ans Toumani"
9) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
10) Grinderman - "Grinderman 2"

Rolling Stone
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
3) Elton John and Leon Russel - "The Union"
4) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
5) Jamey Johnson - "The Guitar Song"
6) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
7) Drake - "Thank me Later"
8) Robert Plant - "Band of Joy"
9) Eminen - "Recovery"
10) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"

Mojo
1) John Grant - "Queen of Denmark"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) MGMT - "Congratulations"
4) Edwyn Colllins - "Losing Sleep"
5) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
6) Paul Weller - "Wake up the Nation"
7) Midlake - "The Courage of Others"
8) Phosphorescent - "Here's to Taking it Easy"
9) The Coral - "Butterfly House"
10) Doug Paisley - "Constant Companion"

Pitchfork
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
3) Deerhunter - "Halcyon Digest"
4) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"
5) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
6) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
7) Joanna Newsom - "Have One on Me"
8) James Blake - "The Bells Sketch / CMYK / Klavierwerke"
9) Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti - "Before Today"
10) Titus Andronicus - "The Monitor"

Gigwise
1) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
2) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
3) The National - "High Violet"
4) Drake - "Thank me Later"
5) Everything Everything - "Man Alive"
6) Foals - "Total Life Forever"
7) Caribou - "Swim"
8) These New Puritans - "Hidden"
9) Warpaint - "The Fool"
10) My Chemical Romance - "Danger Days..."

Paste Magazine
1) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
2) Janelle Monae - "The ArchAndroid"
3) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
4) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
5) Titus Andronicus - "The Monitor"
6) Sleigh Bells - "Treats"
7) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
8) Phosphorescent - "Here's to Taking it Easy"
9) Sufjan Stevens - "The Age of Adz"
10) Frightened Robbit - "The Winter of Mixed Drinks"

Guardian
1) Janelle Monae - "The ArchAndroid"
2) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
3) Hot Chip - "One Life Stand"
4) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
5) These New Puritans - "Hidden"
6) Caribou - "Swim"
7) Robyn - "Body Talk"
8) Laura Marling - "I Speak Because I Can"
9) Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti - "Before Today"
10) John Grant - "Queen of Denmark"

Time
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
4) The National - "High Violet"
5) Drake - "Thank me Later"
6) Sufjan Stevens - "The Age of Adz"
7) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
8) Yeasayer - "Odd Blood"
9) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"
10) Beach House - "Teen Dream"

Billboard
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) Robyn - "Body Talk"
4) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
5) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
6) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
7) Drake - "Thank me Later"
8) MGMT - "Congratulations"
9) Ricky Ross - "Teflon Don"
10) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"

Amazon
1) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
4) The National - "High Violet"
5) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
6) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
7) Broken Bells - "Broken Bells"
8) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
9) Deerhunter - "Halcyon Digest"
10) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"

American Songwriter
1) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
2) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
3) Dylan Le Blanc - "Pauper's Field"
4) Jamey Johnson - "The Guitar Song"
5) Yeasayer - "Odd Blood"
6) Robert Plant - "Band of Joy"
7) Phosphorescent - "Here's to Taking it Easy"
8) Neil Young - "Le Noise"
9) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
10) Laura Veirs - "July Flame"

Relevant
1) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
4) The Roots - "How I Got Over"
5) John Mark Mc Millan - "The Medicine"
6) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
7) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
8) Janelle Monae - "The ArchAndroid"
9) The National - "High Violet"
10) Local Natives - "Gorilla Manor"

Filter
1) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
2) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
3) Mumford and Sons - "Sign no More"
4) The National - "High Violet"
5) The Walkmen - "Lisbon"
6) Gorillaz - "Plastic Beach"
7) Surfer Blood - "Astro Coast"
8) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
9) The Tallest Man on Earth - "The Wild Hunt"
10) Band of Horses - "Infinite Arms"

Magnet
1) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) The National - "High Violet"
4) Broken Bells - "Broken Bells"
5) Superchunk - "Majesty Shredding"
6) Jenny and Johnny - "I'm Having Fun Now"
7) Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti - "Before Today"
8) Teenage FanClub - "Shadows"
9) The Black Keys - "Brothers"
10) The New Pornographers - "Together"

Stereogum
1) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
2) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
3) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
4) Sufjan Stevens - "The Age of Adz"
5) Robyn - "Body Talk"
6) Sleigh Bells - "Treats"
7) Vampire Weekend - "Contra"
8) Antony And The Johnsons - "Swanlights"
9) Wild Nothing - "Gemini"
10) Deerhunter - "Halcyon Digest"

Clash
1) Arcade Fire - "The Suburbs"
2) Ganjasufi - "A Sufi and Killer"
3) Caribou - "Swim"
4) Pantha Du Prince - "Black Noise"
5) Beach House - "Teen Dream"
6) Band of Horses - "Infinite Arms"
7) Foals - "Total Life Forever"
8) Matthew Dear - "Black City"
9) LCD Soundsystem - "This is Happening"
10) These New Puritans - "Hidden"

Metacritic (discos com maior pontuação durante o ano)
1) Bruce Springsteen - "The Promisse"
2) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"
3) Janelle Monae - "The ArchAndroid"
4) Jamey Johnson - "The Guitar Song"
5) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"
6) Underoath - "0"
7) Crime in Stereo - "I Was Trying to Describe You to Someone"
8) Ali Farka Toure and Toumani Diabata - "Ali ans Toumani"
9) Shakira - "Sale el Sol"
10) Marc Ribot - "Silent Movies"

BBC - Music Blog
1) Drake - "Thank me Later"
2) Deftones - "Diamond Eyes"
3) The Roots - "How I Got Over"
4) Big Boi - "Sir Lucious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty"
5) Kanye West - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted"


Sandro

7 comentários:

  1. Completíssimo post! Parabens! Alguem ainda tem alguma duvida que o ano foi para Arcade Fire?!
    Bjoks

    ResponderExcluir
  2. que lindo, o "suburbs" do arcade fire marcando presença praticamente em todas!
    Cara, acho o Caribou e o These new puritans, frequentadores das listas tbem, muuuito chatos. Vê por aí como listas são polêmicas né?
    Um prazerzão conhecer vcs pessoalmente este ano! Nos vemos em 2011!
    abraço

    ResponderExcluir
  3. Meninas, obrigado pela visita! Um ótimo Natal para vocês e muito sucesso aos seus
    excelentes blogs em 2011.

    Beijos


    Bolinho, o prazer foi nosso. Tanto eu quanto o Anselmo esperamos poder encontrá-lo também em 2011. Grande Natal e sucesso ao Indie.Punk.Pop.

    Abraços


    Sandro

    ResponderExcluir
  4. Aeh pessoal, esse ano foi bem legal...espero que o proximo seja melhor ainda!!!!!!

    O post, impecável!

    Anselmo

    ResponderExcluir
  5. The program comes with full warranty 60 days money back,
    so everyone can actually try this muscle building system for
    a few weeks and see the results without any risk at all.

    Many people wish to increase their lean muscle mass and create your toned, developed body that is not only aesthetically
    attractive, but strong and healthy additionally. Then opt for ones cheapest way to help you feed those
    guns while using the Egg White peptids.

    my webpage Somanabolic Muscle Maximizer Results

    ResponderExcluir
  6. As mentioned, thousands of people have already seen
    life changing results after using Kyle Leon's Muscle Maximizer for just a few weeks, and there is nothing that says that you can't
    experience the same changes as well. To find out if it is actually true and to understand better if Kyle Leon's system is generally for you or not, let's
    look into a few of the benefits and drawbacks of the product.
    It will never feature large degrees of filler information,
    or even lengthy explanations.

    Here is my site ... Muscle Maximizer Review

    ResponderExcluir

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...